Merchants Cigar Bar Just Became A Serious Contender For New York's Ultimate Man Cave

One by one, through the years, Manhattan's cigar bars have been winnowed out. It's sad, but only the strong survive.

Advertisement

Merchants Cigar Bar, located on East 61st and 1st Ave, is one of those survivors. They've been around for 15 years, and they want to be around for another hundred.

That's why the Merchants team decided to overhaul their space to make it a true destination — the food, the drinks, everything has been reassembled by some of the most genius minds in New York hospitality.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

The new cocktail menu was designed by mixiologist Jeremy Strawn, the man behind Mulberry Project. The new dinner menu has been personally overhauled by Wade Burch, a winner of Food Network's Chopped competition.

General Manager Chris Eldridge told us that the food is "classic meat and potatoes", and for the best meat in Manhattan, no one compares to butcher Pat LaFrieda — so that's where Merchants is picking up their dry-aged steaks.

Advertisement

It's also worth noting that Merchants is the only cigar bar open til 4 am — so it's almost never too late to light up.

Advertisement

We got to Merchants in time for dinner and cocktails.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

The upstairs portion of the bar is now Neely's, a restaurant collaboration between the famous Food Network couple and Merchants Hospitality Inc.

We headed downstairs. If you've been there before, you'll notice that they knocked down a bunch of walls.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

The smoking space used to be sectioned off. In the new renovations, those walls were knocked down and the ventilation was vastly improved. It's also way better this way for parties.

Advertisement

The bar, though, stayed the same.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

Management sent us an array of new cocktails to try. They're all $15.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider
Advertisement

This is the Gershwin — gin, fresh berries, lemon, rose.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

The Gold Rush — Thankyou Sasha Elijah Craig 12yr Bourbon, Lemon, Honey

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider
Advertisement

The Cadillac Margarita — Centenarian silver, lime juice, Cointreu, Grand Marinier

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

The Volstead — Grey Goose Vodka, Muddled Strawberries, St. Germain, Lemon Juice, Topped with Champagne

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider
Advertisement

The Upper East Side Swizzle — Rum, Velvet Falernium, Lime, Mint, Ginger Ale, Single Barrel Bitters

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

Along with our drinks, we had a lovely tuna tartare.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

Guys, this is one of the many items on the menu that even the girliest girlfriends will not turn up their noses at. The Chef wanted it that way.

Advertisement

These are humidors for your cigars. For $700 per year you can become a member. Up to two people can use each humidor to store their cigars.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

There are other perks as well. Members get 10% off of all their tabs and get a seat in the house no matter what. There are 56 humidors in the restaurant.

We think the best part is that your humidor has a plaque with your name (or nickname) on it.  Our favorites were "Iron Man" and "Little Rascals."

We couldn't resist, we tried some cigars.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

Since we were first timers, we went for a milder cigar called the Tatiana Vanilla.

Advertisement

If you really want to light a cigar, you're supposed to use cedar wood first.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

Then twirl the cigar slowly in your fingers so that it's evenly burned.

Do not inhale. Savor your cigar.

Cigar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider
Advertisement

Wade Burch is the head chef for all of Merchants Inc. He personally oversaw the menu overhaul.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

"At this restaurant, we're doing local," he told Business Insider. "Local cheese, meat from Pat LaFrieda, Jersey tomatoes, Lobster from Maine... Smoking a cigar is something you do that takes a while."

The food reflects that.

Advertisement

And in case you didn't know, Burch is a Chopped champion.

Here's the Chopped Holiday competition where he took home the gold:

Advertisement

Burch told us his favorite cut of steak is the rib eye, and no lie, it was awesome.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

He explained that the rib eye has the most fat around it, and so, the most flavor. "The filet is boring...people are always adding sauces to make a meal out of it," said Burch.

Another Chef favorite on the menu is the lobster slider. Eli's makes a special bread for him and in general, Merchants cant keep lobster for more than a few hours before the patrons order it away.

After dinner, we finished our cigars and sat back. We HIGHLY recommend this experience.

Merchants Cigar Bar
Julia La Roche/Business Insider

The patrons were chill, the service was great, and we're jealous of the humidors.

Advertisement

Then again, maybe you're looking for somewhere without smoke.

peter luger, steakhouse, steak, march 2012, bi, dng
Daniel Goodman / Business Insider

REVEALED: The Best Place To Get A Steak On Wall Street>

Advertisement
Close icon Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification.