Omaha Prime

We came with a group for NYE and it was all of our first time. I have to say, I was definitely impressed. The food and service were great, my steak was perfectly cooked and the sides were delicious.

The restaurant itself could do with a bit of updating, especially the bathrooms. It was also a bit on the pricey side, about $100/pp and we brought our own wine.

All in all, a good steakhouse to have in your rotation in Omaha!

Wonderful meal. The ambiance of the restaurant was inviting and the staff were attentive to our needs throughout the evening.

From the appetizers to the main courses and desserts, every bite was bursting with flavor.
Fresh, high-quality ingredients was evident in every dish. It's clear that they take pride in their culinary creations.

The service was exceptional as well. The waitstaff were knowledgeable about the menu and made excellent recommendations based on our preferences. They were prompt in attending to our needs and ensured that we had everything we needed for an enjoyable dining experience.

Overall, our team dinner was a memorable and delightful experience. The combination of excellent service and delicious food truly enhanced our dining experience. We left the restaurant feeling satisfied and happy, and we look forward to returning in the future.

Had an incredible meal at Omaha Prime. The service was spot on without being pretentious. The location is super cool and quirky.

Pricey, but worth it, especially for any special occasion! My steak was cooked to perfection and the Brussel sprouts were amazing. One side dish is plenty for two.

Our second visit to Omaha Prime did not disappoint. We had the pleasure of being waited on by Bella again. She is a fantastic server and really made our meal memorable. The steaks were delicious and the drinks were great. I highly recommend Omaha Prime as the best steakhouse in town, especially in the Old Market. Ask for Bella!

Wanted to like this place soooo badly, but our experience was absolutely horrendous.

We were greeted by what seemed like a host in training (or maybe just a helicopter of an owner). The first thing they told us about was the location of the bathrooms (hmmm.. probably wouldn't start a guest's experience with that) and asked if we had a reservation like HMMM not sure if we can fit you in... ok the place was empty.

We were seated upstairs and we asked if we could be outside (as it was the nicest weather day of the entire summer) and they noted the patio was closed. Let's note they have literally the most dreamy outdoor section of all time. They said that section was closed. I do understand, but it was 8pm in the summer, at a steakhouse, and the patio is literally on the other side of the windows from the table we were sat at.

We waited indoors for 5-10 minutes and were not greeted, and not brought water. Servers constantly walked right past us. Finally, once greeted we asked once again if there was any way we could be outdoors, as the place was so quiet it didn't seem like it would be the end of the world for them to make an exception. At this point, it was clear that there must be a power struggle going on at this establishment because the servers were so certain management wouldn't allow it, although those tables are literally 2 feet away from our current table inside.

We finally were allowed to go outdoors, and minutes later they allowed another table to be sat near us on the patio. Again, no service, no water... nothing. Then, the topper on the cake was the other table seated outdoors without a struggle.. was greeted immediately, got water, and their drink order. Still no water or nod to us that we were even there. No water, now we are 15 minutes into the experience.

Clearly, there was mass miscommunication at this establishment, and total lack of teamwork. We really tried to wait it out, but decided our time at this steak house would have to come to an end before even receiving water. We really wanted to like this place because the patio was so dreamy and relaxing, but enough is enough. We took a few photos of this historic place, and left.. never to return.. not worth it.

Trying to make last minute reservations for a steakhouse in Omaha is difficult. So they get an extra star for being able to accommodate that. Otherwise it was a very disappointing meal and service. The filet mignon was a good cut, but 1 out of 2 was over cooked to the point of having burnt and dry ends, it was supposed to medium rare. The sides were not good at all. The potato's had little flavor, the Brussels sprouts were burnt.

The service was extremely slow. The server didn't go over the menu, steak cuts, wine selections. Didn't take the wine glasses when we decided to no wine. So our already small table was cluttered.

The decor is super dated as well. The experience was not worth the money.

Fine dining is something that we rarely treat ourselves to. We both appreciate great food, well put together dishes, and special touches that make an entree unique. I had heard about Omaha Prime through word of mouth and it all looked (from the pictures) and sounded delicious!

One morning one of my friends through asked what days would work best for me and Jason to try out Omaha Prime. A few weeks later after figuring out our schedules he had set up a reservation to trek on down to Old Market and try this local New York Style steakhouse.

We started off dinner with an appetizer of the shrimp cocktail. These came pretty promptly and a great portion size for the two of us workout-a-holics. The shrimp were perfectly cooked and cooled and large as well. When our main dishes started coming out were were so amazed by their beauty and abundance. Our porterhouse was wonderfully cooked to our liking and being able to taste both sides was an experience I'll always remember. Now I can easily tell the difference between a new york strip and filet mignon, but eating them both in one sitting was amazing. Both were delicious in their own unique ways. The mushrooms were wonderful, if I was going to enjoy mushrooms I'd enjoy it sauteed in brandy just like this. Everything we ordered went incredibly well together like a beautiful harmony of notes that create a beautiful song. Even our waiter was a delight to have help us out. We ended our dinner trying a couple of their desserts which were the perfect ending to our evening. The New York cheesecake and key lime pie were just enough rich with the right amount of sweetness.

We are so thankful to Mo and our waiter, our friends who treated us, and this tucked away steakhouse that has more to offer than what it seems. Be sure to make reservations and treat yourself!

My boyfriend and I wanted a steak dinner in Omaha to try the famous steaks. This place was well worth the stop. Our waitress explained every cut of meat and showed us the various cuts. We settled on a 11ounce Fillet and 14 ounce NY strip. Each steak is aged and grilled to perfection. By far the best steak I've had in the US!!

Price wise its on the pricey side however we'll worth it.

Sometimes you need to go straight to the source

And that's what we did in Omaha. We had the best quality steaks we've ever had. Out in the Midwest, where the cows are raised, you won't find a fresher steak. It's hard to describe but the tenderness was unlike anything we've had before. The meats were so juicy and cooked to a perfect rare. We ate every piece so fast in order to enjoy the amazing meats.

The truffle cheesy mashed potatoe side was phenomenal paired with our steaks and red wine.

There are so many steakhouses to choose from in Omaha but this one was a fantastic classic one. The vibe was old school and not much frills with great service. They truly let the quality of food dominate the experience. Highly recommend!